15 Comments
User's avatar
Dana Leigh Lyons's avatar

Such a thought-provoking read,Kate! Our minds…externalized…times a trillion.

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

I love your way of seeing the screen problem as an expansion of the human weaknesses we already have. This rings true.

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

So glad it resonates, Tara! In some ways it feels like a way to let ourselves off the hook a bit and be kinder to ourselves, because our screen addictions aren't just about a lack of willpower - it goes much deeper than that.

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

I’ve been reading the book Stolen Focus, which agrees that it’s not an individual problem. I’m almost to the “solution” chapters!

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

Oh yes, this has been on my radar for a while - knowing there are 'solution' chapters bumps it up my list a bit!

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

It’s a really good read! I can’t speak for the solutions yet, but I expect they won’t be individual. :-)

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

It’s a really good read! I can’t speak for the solutions yet, but I expect they won’t be individual. :-)

Expand full comment
Seth Lorinczi's avatar

Love the bit about senses other than vision being, in effect, demoted. It reminds me of '60s sci-fi movies in which aliens always have giant heads at the expense of the rest of their bodies. What are we prioritizing at the expense of our own wholeness?

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

Yes! Demoted is a great word for it. And funny you should mention aliens, because this guy from early 2000s Doctor Who was v much in my head while writing: https://zarbi.fandom.com/wiki/Face_of_Boe

Expand full comment
Seth Lorinczi's avatar

Oh sure. THAT guy! This is pegging me generationally, but this is who I had in mind:

https://img1.wsimg.com/isteam/ip/f3cb52a5-3079-4fd3-bed4-5b289ecfc152/talosian.jpg/:/rs=w:1280

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

Ha! Yep, also works 😂

Expand full comment
Annabel Vickers's avatar

It seems like the concept of attention is doing the rounds a bit at the moment and it’s so fascinating. Ezra Klein’s latest podcast episode, which I listened to today, talks a lot about this and the role our phones/social media have on how we feel and our ability to focus. Definitely recommend giving jt a listen!

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

Ooh that sounds good, thanks for the rec! The Guardian also has a 'how to break up with your phone' type programme going on for January (naturally signed up immediately) and I keep seeing Substack posts about people leaving Instagram...I wonder if some sort of sea change is coming...?

Expand full comment
Ugrid's avatar

time to get a flip phone!

Expand full comment
Kate Brook's avatar

Alas, I can't :( Everyone is getting so paranoid about cyber security I now have to verify my identity via an app before I can log in to various work systems. Literally couldn't do my job without a smartphone

Expand full comment